| Platinum | Grandad's Donuts |
| Gold |
Matty's Hot Chicken
|
| Silver | Sweet Paradise |
| Bronze | Bennett's Apples & Cider |
| Top Pick | Copper Kettle Cafe |
| Top Pick | Country Style |
| Top Pick | Darling Donuts |
| Top Pick | Donut Monster |
| Top Pick | Weil's of Westdale Bakery & Pastry Shoppe |
