| Platinum | Mikey's Cream Pies |
| Gold | Cake & Loaf Bakery |
| Gold | Crumbuns Bakeshop |
| Gold | Sweet Paradise |
| Gold | Weil's of Westdale Bakery & Pastry Shoppe |
| Silver | Aristos Greek Bakery |
| Bronze | Boa Bakery |
| Top Pick | Bennett's Apples & Cider |
| Top Pick | Hamilton Meat Pie Co. |
| Top Pick | Karen's Kool Kreations |
| Top Pick | Punch Bowl Market & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Sam's Queenston Bakery |