| Platinum | Valentino's Restaurant |
| Gold | La Spaghett Pasta House |
| Silver | Chicago Style Pizza |
| Bronze | Castelli Cucina |
| Top Pick | Bronzie's Place |
| Top Pick | Cafe Limoncello |
| Top Pick | Capri Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Caro Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Giuseppe's Italian Cuisine & Pizza |
| Top Pick | La Cantina Ristorante |