| Platinum | Mikey's Cream Pies |
| Gold | Bitten Cupcakes and Whoopie Pies |
| Silver | Roma Bakery |
| Bronze | I’ll Crumble For You |
| Top Pick | A Tablespoon of Time |
| Top Pick | Aristos Greek Bakery |
| Top Pick | Batches Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Cake and Kale |
| Top Pick | Fairly Frosted |
| Top Pick | Sharpe Cravings |