| Platinum | Chasing Shadows Productions |
| Platinum | Hamilton Academy of Performing Arts |
| Platinum | Playful Fox Productions |
| Gold | Slap Entertainment and Productions |
| Silver | Emerson Arts Theatrical Productions |
| Bronze | Crown Point Players |
| Top Pick | Curtain Call Performing Arts Company |
| Top Pick | Curtain Call Performing Arts Company Dani Viola |
| Top Pick | Hamilton Theatre |
| Top Pick | Westdale Theater Group - Not for Profit |