| Platinum | Starsky Fine Foods |
| Gold | Denninger's Foods of the World |
| Silver | Zarky's Fine Foods |
| Bronze | The Urban Vine |
| Top Pick | Bennett's Apples & Cider |
| Top Pick | Delusional Sauce Co |
| Top Pick | Hamilton Market General Store |
| Top Pick | Nardini Specialties |
| Top Pick | Wally Parr Sausage |
| Top Pick | Watermark Taphouse & Grille |