| Platinum | Hamilton Theatre |
| Gold | Theatre Aquarius |
| Silver | Hamilton Fringe Festival |
| Bronze | Curtain Call Performing Arts Company |
| Top Pick | Chasing Shadows Productions |
| Top Pick | Olivia Jodway - Red Tree Performance Academy |
| Top Pick | Players' Guild of Hamilton, Inc. |
| Top Pick | Playful Fox Productions |
| Top Pick | Red Tree Performance Academy - Sister Act Jr |
| Top Pick | The Staircase Theatre + Lounge |